Professor Michael Osbaldeston, former dean of Cranfield University School of Management in the UK, who is visiting the USB and USB-ED, writes about developing leaders for a global business environment:
Developing Leaders for a Global Business Environment
Professor Michael Osbaldeston
Cranfield University School of Management
Friday, 23 October 2009
Setting the scene
Predicting corporate change and its
implications for management over a long time horizon is a notoriously
difficult and dangerous activity. If anything can be learned from the
recent world financial crisis and economic downturn, it is that the
future business environment will present those responsible for leading
companies with continuous turbulence, requiring them to implement major
change in the ways in which they organise work and manage people.
Managers of the future will face a radically transforming business
world, increasing competitive pressures, resulting particularly from
globalisation, and ever higher levels of personal challenge and stress.
Around the world, organisations in business and management education are grappling with the problem of how to identify and develop the 'competent leader', who will have the skills and abilities to handle such demanding roles in this new business era. Although these organisations vary in size and activity, they share one thing in common ⌐ a strong belief in the strategic importance of human capital. They recognise that their long term competitiveness depends on their ability to develop and utilise the expertise and talent of all their staff. Many are evolving into knowledge-based organisations whose major asset is know-how; others define their goal as becoming learning organisations where continuous development becomes a way of life.
As organisational structures become more diverse and complex, many businesses have moved towards flatter, decentralised structures in order to become more flexible and market driven. This has led to a growing emphasis on 'horizontal' management, operating primarily through lateral rather than hierarchical relationships, and requires such competencies as clarity of vision, strategic leadership and cross-cultural team working to ensure success. Taken together, these changes are forcing businesses to depend increasingly on people, rather than systems and procedures.
Businesses are increasingly
recognising that they are among the most influential institutions
worldwide, and increasing globalisation affords them an opportunity to
shape a better world for existing and future generations. This requires
globally responsible leaders to
think and act in a global context,
broaden their corporate purpose to reflect accountability to society
around the world, and put ethics at the centre of their thoughts, words
and deeds ie. to adopt a 'triple bottom line' perspective on business
performance. Leadership development is starting to give corporate
global responsibility the centrality it deserves, and business schools
must play a pivotal role, in partnership with businesses, to develop
future leaders who are capable of ensuring that business is a force for
good.
Management for the future
Trends in the business environment and changes in organisational design are placing new and substantial demands on managers. More and more, effective managerial performance involves learning to handle complexity, diversity and ambiguity. As a result, the manager's future role will be to act as:
- A Sensor: managers must have a better understanding of the external influences on the organisations.
- An Integrator: managers will have to manage a more diverse range of lateral relationships, often using sources of influence that do not depend on formal authority.
- A Leader: creative and inspiring leadership will be needed at all levels of an organisation.
- An Animateur: managers will have to mobilise and channel human energy.
- A Focuser: managers must be able to focus on the present and look far into the future.
- An Information User: being able to process and make sense of a profusion of complex data.
These changes imply a more holistic view of the manager's job and reflect a shift in emphasis from what the manager knows to what he/she stands for. They also highlight the growing importance of leadership development. Research shows that organisations are moving from a "fragmented" approach to management training and development, where such activities are peripheral to the organisation, via a more systematic "formalised", to a "focused" approach where training and development are intrinsic to the organisation, and seen as providing competitive advantage.
The focused approach to development
raises important issues for organisations, for managers and for human
resource professionals. Organisations must recognise leadership
development as one component in a continuous process of organisation
development. They should promote learning as a cherished organisational
value and must seek to link training and development to corporate
strategy. They must give careful thought to the nurturing of leadership
skills at all levels of the organisation. Managers themselves need
coaching and mentoring skills to fulfil their growing role as
developers of others. The trainer's wider role will be more demanding,
and much needs to be done to develop the trainers to become
facilitators of continuous learning, rather than teachers of courses.International Management
What is beyond dispute is that managers of the future will have to apply their skills within an increasingly international business environment.
Many larger companies have already recognised that they cannot thrive on domestic markets alone. Indeed, an era is fast approaching where the concept of being a national or a domestic company is losing meaning. Through takeovers, mergers, joint ventures and strategic alliances, companies are fast becoming consortia of smaller organisations, and no longer merely expanding internationally on the basis of the strength of their domestic market share. Their national loyalties are diminishing as they co-ordinate business assets in multiple countries. For example, the Swiss firm Nestle has 4% of its employees based in Switzerland and generates only 2% of its sales there. The Swiss/Swedish engineering company ABB has 111,000 people employed in 100 countries, while Unilever employs more than 200,000 staff spread across 78 countries.
Beyond these statistics, the changing organisational structure of large companies is accelerating the development of a new breed of manager. A previous CEO of ABB said of the company: "There is no parent around the traditional form; all operating companies are sisters. I sit in Zurich presiding over a 100 people in HQ. It will not get larger than that. It is a new concept of a truly global company that we are creating. Some people say we have no home country. The truth is that we have many home countries."
It is important to understand this changing picture of the world in which business operates as it provides the context in which to consider international management. As more and more business is conducted internationally, companies face the increasing challenge of enabling people of different cultures to work effectively together. 'Internationalism' is, therefore, the ability to work with local differences in a global context. The 'international manager' must be able to act locally but think and plan strategically and globally.
Recent research reveals that there are two sides to the abilities needed by international managers. The first involves active or 'doing' competencies, consisting of four main roles:
- Championing international strategy: this means working with other managers around the world to create a vision of the future and formulate strategies to take the organisation forward.
- Cross-border coach and co-ordinator: by collaborating with local management teams to encourage them to contribute their own ideas.
- Intercultural mediator and change agent: making sure you are aware of both your own cultural underpinnings and the need to be sensitive to cultural differences.
- Managing personal effectiveness: handling the stress and travel of an international lifestyle.
- Cognitive complexity: the cultural empathy derived from being able to identify relationships and patterns between different dimensions of a complex situation.
- Emotional energy: resilience to enable risk-taking and handling stressful situations.
- Psychological maturity: a curiosity to learn combined with a strong personal morality and value system.
At every level of analysis, the picture emerging from recent research is one of organisations and individuals having to manage tension and contradictions, where personal and business ethics are crucial in determining how best to respond.
Looking at the broad business context, it is clear that the debate about the role of business in society, and the future impact of economic and social issues on organisations, will increase. While recognising that business will have to re-examine its relationship with the rest of society if both are to prosper, many managers find it difficult to focus on such issues while they continue to face short-term pressures for survival. This conflict between short-term survival goals and long-term prosperity underlies many of the paradoxes facing organisations as they look to the future. It is not a question of choosing between the short and long term; on the contrary, organisations must find ways of simultaneously satisfying the demands of both. The successful organisation of the future will be one that has reconciled the conflicting pressures:
- Between the short and long term
- Between internationalisation and serving key local markets.
- Between sticking to core activities and diversifying into new strategic alliances.
- An increasing regard for corporate responsibility with organisations taking account of their impact on a wide range of stakeholders.
- The development of a widely dispersed workforce supported by the growing use of information technology and telecommunications.
- An increasing link between rewards and performance, combined with ways of encouraging a sense of employee ownership in companies.
- Leadership development becoming a process of continuous learning, rather than periodic training courses.
While the success of some well publicised organisational change programmes has been explained in terms of the 'top-down', vision-led approach of assertive leaders, similar reforms have been related to 'bottom-up', facilitating leadership styles. Looking to the future, the need for transformational change will be ever increasing, but the days of the 'heroic' leader are on the wane, as the consequences of creating an over-dependent culture are more clearly recognised. Increasingly, organisations are seeking to develop 'managerial leadership' at all levels, through a flexible combination of a range of skills and styles:
Organisations need to combine:
- Administrative Leadership: getting things done
- Supervisory Leadership: doing things right
- Strategic Leadership: doing the right things
- Inspirational Leadership: inspiring the doing
The way forward
There is often a tendency to develop a 'wish list' of the perfect manager, but deeper analysis reveals a surprising consistency about the key competencies required of the manager of the future. This consistency lies more at the level of attitudes than skills: where managers need to develop a 'mindset' which is constantly in tune with both the internal organisational context and the complex and turbulent business environment. This mindset encompasses a number of inherent demands and tensions:
- The need for managers to have a strong sense of the whole organisation to underpin their internal interactions, while at the same time being acutely aware of the external environment, to anticipate and respond to its constant changes.
- A heavy emphasis on task or 'doing' skills to achieve high performance and successful outcomes, while at the same time, the way in which managers approach tasks will be equally important, requiring highly developed behavioural skills.
- A healthy scepticism towards theory and a focus on action, while at the same time, placing value on reflection and looking ahead, with 'strategic thinking' being the priority skill for the future.
- Individuals will need to take on responsibility for their own development, being no longer able to rely on career ladders within one organisation, while at the same time, the key role of teams is being emphasised, requiring the skills to collaborate with other people in temporary and non-hierarchical groups.
"Instead of seeing the rug being pulled from under us,
we can learn to dance on a shifting carpet."





